Bordeaux 2009 & 2010: Equal, Yet Unequal?

October 15, 2015

A number of Bordeaux estates hold exactly the same score for their 2009 and 2010 vintages yet the pricing for both is rarely equal. Liv-ex recently pointed out the price disparity between the ’09 and ’10 vintages of Château Montrose where, despite both having 100-points from The Wine Advocate, the 2009 remains 12% more expensive than the 2010.

However, it would appear this is a situation not unique to Montrose. Liv-ex has dug a little deeper and found 22 estates where both the ‘09 and ‘10 vintages have the same score from The Wine Advocate but where the price has swung in favor of one or other of those vintages, sometimes quite dramatically.

The full list can be seen below and Liv-ex adds that a 5% swing either way is a reasonable variation and half the wines on the list exhibit this sort of volatility.

Nonetheless, there remain eight wines where the disparity is far more than 5% in favor of either the ‘09 or ‘10.

Continue reading: The Drinks Business





Also in News

2016 Bordeaux: Reevaluating in the Bottle
2016 Bordeaux: Reevaluating in the Bottle

March 18, 2019

The 2016 Bordeaux vintage received stellar scores when tasted en primeur. Now, the in bottle tasting reviews are coming in with quite a few perfect scores, and Liv-ex has been tallying them and analyzing prices to see if a) the scores are holding up and b) if the relative value is in the consumer’s favor.

Continue Reading

Burgundy Leads Sales
Burgundy Leads Sales

March 15, 2019

Sotheby’s, one of the leaders in selling fine wine, has relayed that their sales went from 64 million in 2017 to over 100 million in 2018. The leading sales were in Burgundy, with sales of Domaine Romanée-Conti fetching record heights.

Continue Reading

Amarone for the win! What to Expect in This Fine Red Wine’s Future
Amarone for the win! What to Expect in This Fine Red Wine’s Future

March 13, 2019

Anteprima Amarone, an event bringing out both the new Amarone vintage and its makers to take measure of the wine’s place in the world, was held recently, bringing into focus both the wine’s strengths and weaknesses.

Continue Reading